Praise Beyond “Good Job”: How to Give Employees Recognition That Matters

“Sales and account managers always get shout-outs. What about us?”
“So many edits and revisions. Do they like anything I do?”
“I worked really hard on that event, then no one said anything. Was it terrible?”
When employees don’t regularly hear recognition from their manager, anxieties like these often begin to crop up. If all they hear is criticism, vague feedback, or silence, they may wonder whether their contributions are valued or even noticed.
That’s why this Thanksgiving season, we’re focusing on gratitude as a real leadership skill worth developing. Managers often think they appreciate their team enough, but employees still don’t feel it. Generic, infrequent recognition can leave people feeling overlooked, while employees who feel appreciated tend to stay longer, work harder, and build a positive culture.
Research backs it up: In 2024, Gallup and Workhuman found that employees who receive valuable feedback at work are 57% less likely to feel burned out and 48% less likely to be job hunting. Here’s how to give employee recognition effectively, especially when it doesn’t come naturally to you.
What Quality Recognition Looks Like
In our experience at Berger HR Solutions, employee recognition works best when it’s:
- Specific
- Timely
- Personal
Be Specific: Let people know the work they do is noticed and appreciated. Praise the idea shared in the brainstorming session or the positive customer experience someone provided.
Instead of a quick “Nice work, team,” after the meeting, try, “I appreciated how you stayed calm when the client changed direction. Great job providing them with workable next steps.”
Be Timely: If you think something positive, say it. If you aren’t able to immediately, jot it in your planner to share in your next meeting, or send a message later. This helps you remember specific praise in place of vague platitudes.
Be Personal: Know your team and how they like to be recognized. Some people appreciate a public shout-out in front of the whole company or department. Others would prefer a private note from you. Some appreciate frequent, informal acknowledgment; others value a more thoughtful note at key milestones.
Read Also: 5 Strategies to Show Your Employees Gratitude at Thanksgiving & Holidays
Who Should Recognize Employees?
Ideally, all levels of management should recognize their employees, whether they’re a team lead, middle manager, or senior manager.
If you’re a senior manager and don’t work with many staff members directly, ask the leaders below you to routinely share who’s doing great work. That way, during all-hands meetings or town halls, you can shout out these individuals or teams, even if you don’t directly oversee the work they’re doing.
How Often Should I Give Employees Recognition?
Gallup finds that employees are significantly more engaged when they receive recognition weekly or several times a week. Unfortunately, the same study found that only 14% are given weekly recognition.
Weekly recognition may sound like a lot, but it doesn’t have to be a big show. Just a quick message or Slack comment saying, “Thanks for covering this!” or “Nice work on the proposal!” can go a long way.
Is There Such a Thing as Too Much Recognition?
As long as positive feedback is truly honest and authentic, you shouldn’t worry about praising your employees too much. However, it can become a problem when recognition turns into favoritism.
Be mindful of who you recognize most often. During all-staff meetings, is the sales team consistently praised, but not other departments? When was the last time administrators, HR, or marketing received a shout-out? Even if top performers deserve accolades, try to spread the recognition.
Uncomfortable Giving Feedback?
Some managers feel uncomfortable providing constructive feedback—and that’s completely understandable. (For that, read our guide to difficult conversations). But what about positive feedback? You may have heard of the leader who’s “quick to criticize, slow to praise.” What causes it?
Some managers may fear that giving too much praise will encourage people to slack off or ‘coast by.’ Others may worry about appearing ‘phony’ or think recognizing direct reports is a sign of weakness. Some managers never had a good role model for positive feedback; they only saw their bosses point out errors and faults.
Many managers want to give kudos, but they are so busy that the day slips by without a chance to share a quick message praising a job well done. That’s why gratitude and recognition must be habits built into a leader’s routine. If finding the time or will to share feedback is hard for you, try:
- Keeping notes when someone does a good job
- Marking your calendar for work anniversaries
- Blocking time on your calendar to review recently completed work and look for opportunities to provide feedback
Recognition doesn’t have to be elaborate or time-consuming. When it’s specific, timely, and personal, you don’t need to worry about it feeling forced or turning into empty praise. Most people already know they’re doing good, hard work. What they want is to know that someone noticed.
This Thanksgiving season is a natural time to start. Pick one person on your team this week and tell them exactly what you appreciated about their work. Then build the habit from there.
If recognition and feedback don’t come naturally to you or your managers, you’re not alone, and it’s a skill that can be learned. Berger HR Solutions helps small and mid-sized businesses build stronger leaders through leadership training, so your team feels valued and your best people stay.
Contact us at info@bergerhrsolutions.com or 410-695-9888 to learn more.